====================================================================== PE-WJ-Diplo [OckerBoy]: again Hermis, again Date:Sun, 14 May 2006 11:15:02 +0000 To reply, log in at http://www.powersedge.net/?Page=Login or use your newspaper form. Direct email replies do not go to the sender. (This is intended to protect the privacy of other players.) ====================================================================== again Hermis you have escaped any attempt at a tit-for-tat strike!!! You stole Quongan which I was preparing to sell to Imutnab and my connecting region to Quongan disappears in a diaster!!! The disasters always work against me, never for me!!! ====================================================================== PE-WJ-Diplo [Hermis]: re: again Hermis, again Date:Sun, 14 May 2006 19:14:41 +0000 To reply, log in at http://www.powersedge.net/?Page=Login or use your newspaper form. Direct email replies do not go to the sender. (This is intended to protect the privacy of other players.) ====================================================================== OckerBoy, it was the time when disaster was for you. You should appreciate this. :) ====================================================================== PE-WJ-Announce [Moderator]: Alliances and Restarts Date: Sun, 14 May 2006 20:43:13 +0000 Announcement from the Moderator to All Leaders: Professor's situation raises a rules question: Should a leader who restarts be allowed to leave an alliance? The rules make it clear that alliance membership is permanent, so certainly one can't leave an alliance while one is still alive. On the other hand, someone who is wiped out, and then restarts later under a different name, certainly isn't a member of the alliance any more. Professor's situation (as someone who restarts and gives up everything except his old name) falls in the middle. What do people think? My inclination is to say that once you restart, you're a free agent again. It wouldn't be fair to punish an alliance by saddling it with a newborn nation as a fighting partner. But on the other hand, as long as the Leader's name lives, a lot of diplomatic history is preserved. -- Power's Edge, http://www.powersedge.net/ P.S. If you are no longer playing, please use the Resign button in your newspaper to resign. After your resignation goes through, you will no longer receive these messages. ====================================================================== PE-WJ-Diplo [OckerBoy]: old name, new game Date:Sun, 14 May 2006 22:28:14 +0000 To reply, log in at http://www.powersedge.net/?Page=Login or use your newspaper form. Direct email replies do not go to the sender. (This is intended to protect the privacy of other players.) ====================================================================== I reckon they could just adjust their name a little bit, like, in this example, 'The Prof' or something. And then make a public statement recant their erstwhile allies. Make the dirt public, that sort of thing. :-) Ockerboy ====================================================================== PE-WJ-Diplo [OckerBoy]: old name, new game Date:Sun, 14 May 2006 22:29:07 +0000 To reply, log in at http://www.powersedge.net/?Page=Login or use your newspaper form. Direct email replies do not go to the sender. (This is intended to protect the privacy of other players.) ====================================================================== I reckon they could just adjust their name a little bit, like, in this example, 'The Prof' or something. And then make a public statement recanting their erstwhile allies. Make the dirt public, that sort of thing. :-) Ockerboy ====================================================================== PE-WJ-Diplo [Acanthopis]: Alliances and Restarts Date:Mon, 15 May 2006 00:47:59 +0000 To reply, log in at http://www.powersedge.net/?Page=Login or use your newspaper form. Direct email replies do not go to the sender. (This is intended to protect the privacy of other players.) ====================================================================== The more one tries to restrict things, the more complex the rules enforcement becomes. You start having to try to figure out who used to be what and all kinds of other stuff. If you die, or commit suicide, I say that's the end of your nation, and you can come back however you like, and be part of whatever alliance you want. By the way, while I'm talking, I did want to send a quick statement out to the world, because it looks like OckerBoy is ransoming his nation in order to get a few armies so he can be a player. OckerBoy's lands are ill-gotten. Buying them is like buying a TV on a street corner from someone strung out on meth--you're just feeding the habit. I am making a claim on OckerBoy's nation right now. He and I are at war, and once I can get Zabor out of my way, well, then I'll try to collect on the claim I'm staking. So, if you're fighting OckerBoy, I have no argument with you. However, if you buy his lands, from this point on I will assert my right to retake them (obviously this doesn't apply to past purchases). I won't think of my attacking as an act of war, because those lands should not be sold (especially since he'll just use those big armies to take lands from me and my friends). Not that I'm really in a position to threaten, but...you know...with luck, maybe later you'll be at least a little scared... :-) -- Acanthopis ====================================================================== PE-WJ-Diplo [Zabor]: Claims laid by a dead man Date:Mon, 15 May 2006 06:37:27 +0000 To reply, log in at http://www.powersedge.net/?Page=Login or use your newspaper form. Direct email replies do not go to the sender. (This is intended to protect the privacy of other players.) ====================================================================== Hello everybody, Everyone is welcomed take part in campaign against Acanthopis, as he's going to be overrun and he's weakening turn by turn and don't quite have the troops to defend himself. Some of us are anyways going to be so opportunistic that the rest of us got to follow suite. So Free Meals tm (who said there was no such thing?) offered by Zabor at Acanthopis, and no, I'm not laying claim on his areas, just taking what I can, so everyone is welcome to join in on the fun... Yours, -Zabor ps. I like acanthopis, he's a likeable fellow, it's just that he wages war against my teammate that forces my hand. ====================================================================== PE-WJ-Diplo [Kalvis]: Alliances and Restarts Date:Mon, 15 May 2006 07:23:40 +0000 To reply, log in at http://www.powersedge.net/?Page=Login or use your newspaper form. Direct email replies do not go to the sender. (This is intended to protect the privacy of other players.) ====================================================================== I think once leader joins an alliance he should be part of it till the end of universe. If leader restarts, he is still the same leader, with same diplo history. If player wants to leave an alliance after restart, he must change the name, so others would have a chance to not know who he is. Maybe it's just me, but if Kalvis restarts, he still would have simpathies towards members of SA and antipathy towards James. And others would have attitude towards Kalvis based on his past as a member of SA. If I restart as a new leader, then I would be able to reset my diplo memory and could hope that others would treat me as a new leader with no past. Leting go of the old name is leting go of the past. Keeping the name is keeping the obligations associated with it. That is my vote. ====================================================================== PE-WJ-Diplo [Zabor]: Alliances and restarts Date:Mon, 15 May 2006 09:14:48 +0000 To reply, log in at http://www.powersedge.net/?Page=Login or use your newspaper form. Direct email replies do not go to the sender. (This is intended to protect the privacy of other players.) ====================================================================== In my opinion, it wouldd be best to let the player choose the way he's gonna restart, with new or old identity. Think about eg imutnab who pursues an old feud with james, professor would maybe be inclined to do likewise against SA members, so an attempt at cutting all ties to the past has to be done by restarting with new name. Secret grudges if pursued are likely to give away the old identity at some point anyway, so it would be reasonable to leave the decision up to the restarter to choose between new and old identity, and whether he prefers to continue in an alliance or not. my 5 cents. ====================================================================== PE-WJ-Diplo [Arizona]: Professor chose to be in TS Date:Tue, 16 May 2006 14:16:42 +0000 To reply, log in at http://www.powersedge.net/?Page=Login or use your newspaper form. Direct email replies do not go to the sender. (This is intended to protect the privacy of other players.) ====================================================================== I see in the summary of Turn 141, what Professor still belongs to TS. So Bob's question is unreasonable - Prof chose his side and destiny already, entering SA one more time, when put this SA in his nation name. He can restart right now with new name and then we shouldn't chase him for only reason he was in TS. New name means new life by default for everybody. This is a game, not Hague tribunal with bitchy DelPonte haund. That is my 3 kopecks. Arizona ====================================================================== PE-WJ-Diplo [The Sorceress]: Real World Date:Tue, 16 May 2006 21:53:06 +0000 To reply, log in at http://www.powersedge.net/?Page=Login or use your newspaper form. Direct email replies do not go to the sender. (This is intended to protect the privacy of other players.) ====================================================================== Please, Arizona, leave real world out of any PE diplomacy... ====================================================================== PE-WJ-Announce [Moderator]: Restarts / Alliance Membership Date: Tue, 16 May 2006 23:18:11 +0000 Announcement from the Moderator to All Leaders: Okay, let's do this: (1) As in the standard rules, anyone who restarts can keep his/her name if they wish. But those who choose to keep their old name are forewarned that this will saddle their new baby-sized nation with their old diplomatic baggage. (2) If an alliance member restarts, by default they are no longer a member of their previous alliance, and must change their alliance membership "tag" in their nations' name. If the player wants to rejoin the alliance, and the alliance agrees (and still has a slot available), then the alliance must make a public announcement to that effect as usual. -- Power's Edge, http://www.powersedge.net/ P.S. If you are no longer playing, please use the Resign button in your newspaper to resign. After your resignation goes through, you will no longer receive these messages.